Content

Waterfall vs. Agile: Which methodology to choose for your Redmine projects?

waterfall-vs-agile-which-methodology-to-choose-for-your-redmine-projects

Agile vs. Waterfall - In this blog, I'm going to talk about two project management techniques, their benefits, how they can help you and how to combine them.

Sometimes I hear shouts like "Gantt is dead," or "you have to drive it the agile way," or even "project management is dead." Although many of them are just an example of marketing rubbish, I often encounter project portfolio managers, scrum masters, and other project management professionals who want to seriously argue about Agile vs. Waterfall (Gantt) techniques. This post is a brief introduction into the topic.

 

The iron triangle of project management

The iron triangle is actually a very simple representation of the key elements needed for successful project planning. Scope, time and cost/resources. Resources are the only and/or critical element of the price in many industries. People are the most valuable asset that cannot simply be increased, reduced or multiplied. Similarly, machine resources have a certain production capacity and cannot be changed by a simple click.

 

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #1

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #1

 

But how does the iron triangle fit into the overall picture? Very conveniently. It offers us a simple but effective answer when we should use the planning of the Waterwall methodology and, on the contrary, when to choose an agile approach.

 

Redmine Waterfall project management

The Waterfall methodology is best suited to a project whose scope is precisely defined and is a key element of the project, such as real estate construction, conference planning or Easy Redmine software implementation.

Technique: The scope of the project is defined (fixed). In our example, this means that I cannot change the number of windows in my real estate, I cannot change the place or subject of a conference, etc. The project time is a limiting factor either absolutely (e.g. conferencing) or almost absolutely (e.g. software implementation). With a tightly defined scope, the main task of a project manager or portfolio manager is to schedule all types of resources on the timeline across parallel running projects and taking into account the required sequence of actions (tasks) in individual projects.

Consider, for example, the construction of a house: workers responsible for cement delivery have to complete their work in a timely manner because delays caused by a lack of cement resources can prevent bricklayers from completing their own tasks. Once the concrete is firm enough, they can already be found on another site.

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #2

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #2

 

Redmine Agile project management

An agile approach is useful for projects where time is firmly defined, resources are a determining factor and the scope is subject to planning (prioritization). A good example could be software development (sprints), publication activity (magazine/newspaper release date) or marketing content (campaign).

Technique: scrum masters or planners in similar roles prioritize tasks for the next sprint. Usually, the scrum master has different backlogs and scrum boards for different types of resources, such as developers looking to fix bugs and handle requests for new features and, on the other side, journalists in political or sports media.

 

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #3

Easy Redmine - The iron triangle #3

 

What does it mean?

Obviously, the whole issue of project management is still turning around the iron triangle. Operational planning only focuses more on different parts of the same thing. So what can we draw from it?

  1. Virtually in each organization, we would find types of projects where it is necessary to use the both project management techniques for creating efficient working processes. One methodology is not better than the other, it just addresses different challenges.

  2. Quality scheduling of resources associated with the timeline is essential for each Waterfall project, and especially for project portfolio planning. The same is true for Easy Redmine projects.

  3. Managing agile projects: Managing priorities is usually done through various tools. Often, there is a problem of accurate resource allocation for a specific backlog. So, in this respect, I strongly recommend that you map and allocate your resources consistently. For example, a software developer can be used with multiple backlogs at the same time (e.g. bug fixes vs. function requests in the same language). Without defining quantitative resource allocation to backlogs, however, you will not be able to schedule priority deliverables, and the scrum master will have to continually resolve discrepancies between these priorities. Another unpleasant consequence will be the delayed release of new key product features such as bug fixes or feature requirements, which exploit strategic development resources.

 

Combination of both management methodologies

As you can see in the picture below, we have a basic Waterfall project that includes some software development plan that shows sequences and dependencies. However, teams involved in this project (salesmen, technical writers) can manage their own deliveries in their department not only as shown in this example but also the agile way.

 

Easy Redmine - Waterfall project example

Easy Redmine Gantt - Waterfall project example

 

Read also "How to properly balance planning and creativity in your Redmine project".

 

Author: Lukáš Beňa

10.07.17

Qué es Easy Redmine

Easy Redmine es un software de código abierto para la gestión de proyectos complejos con extensiones para los recursos, las finanzas o la gestión de clientes. Ya sea en la nube o en su propio servidor, incluye implementación profesional y mantenimiento.

¿Qué opinan los usuarios acerca de Easy Redmine en Capterra?

  • ¡Un producto muy útil!

    Apr 6, 2016

    Nuestro entorno de trabajo se basa exclusivamente en el producto de easy redmine - tareas, objetivos-, lo gestionamos todo en una misma plataforma que nos ayuda a planificar, observar los progresos y mucho más.

    Alon Almog
    IT , Gita Technologies
    5/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Gestión de proyectos sencilla y consistente

    Apr 21, 2016

    ¡EasyRedmine es todo un avance comparado con Redmine! Ofrece más funcionalidades gracias a todos sus complementos. Interfaz de uso mejorado. Una atención al cliente muy reactiva y profesional.

    Departamento de IT
    Monaco Paradigm
    5/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Mejor control de los costes y de los recursos humanos

    Mar 24, 2016

    Implantamos Easy Redmine hace seis meses para controlar todos nuestros proyectos web. Estamos encantados ya que ahora hemos ganado una fuerte visibilidad en el sentido de control de costes y de recursos humanos, y además contamos con una potente herramienta para interactuar con nuestros clientes.

    Cyril Lécot
    Jefe de Operaciones , Netquarks
    4/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Solución todo en uno para la gestión de proyectos

    Apr 5, 2016

    Easy Redmine es un software fantástico que nos ayuda a gestionar los costes de los proyectos y a definir mejor nuestro trabajo que está repleto de opciones que faltaban en Redmine. Y todo ello integrado en una interfaz muy fácil de usar.

    Nelson Rodrigues
    Belo Solutions
    4/5
    Información general
    4/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Soluciones Help Desk

    Jun 29, 2016

    Una solución profesional con un montón de opciones. Nos permite gestionar nuestros clientes de una forma más eficiente. Muy recomendable especialmente si la tuya es una empresa de IT.

    Felicien Bikang
    WORLD-INNOV.COM
    5/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Un gran software para planificar y realizar informes de IT

    Apr 6, 2016

    Nosotros empleamos Easy Redmine todos los días para planificar proyectos y todos los empleados controlan el tiempo que trabajo con la fantástica opción del temporizador.

    Mattias Eriksson
    Jefe de equipo , People and Solutions AB
    5/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Un montón de complementos útiles

    Jun 11, 2016

    Akquinet lleva utilizando Redmine durante años. Nos encantan todos los complementos extra y la ayuda que Easy Redmine nos proporciona para que podamos concentrarnos en nuestro trabajo.

    Konrad Mattheis
    Director de Consultoría , Akquinet
    5/5
    Información general
    4/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Una aplicación todo en uno: eso es Easy Redmine

    Aug 25, 2015

    RTL Radio utiliza Easy Redmine para mantener help desk, recursos, participación y, por supuesto, proyectos de software. Nos encanta su complejidad; utilizar una solución todo en uno es sencillamente maravilloso.

    Timo Muller
    Jefe de Información , RTL Radio Deutschland GmbH
    5/5
    Información general
    5/5
    Facilidad de uso
    5/5
    Atención al cliente
  • Una potente herramienta de gestión de proyectos

    Apr 27, 2016

    Interfaz sencilla y fácil de usar. Flexible y personalizable para tus propias necesidades.

    Helen Tang
    Cherrypicks
    4/5
    Información general
    4/5
    Facilidad de uso
    4/5
    Atención al cliente

Capterra es una plataforma independiente.

PRUÉBELO GRATISEn una versión de prueba de 14 días Versión de prueba gratuita y completa Con certificado SLL Copia de seguridad diaria

.easyredmine.com

we will call you to help with settings

no requiere tarjeta de crédito, no necesita instalación